Pandora remains the king of Internet radio for now. The online music service’s position atop the sector has been in question ever since Apple announced it was launching a direct competitor, but Pandora has fended off iTunes Radio fairly effectively since it debuted in September. The company posted record revenues in its most recent quarter of $180.4 million, beating analyst expectations. The net loss of $1.7 million was down from a $2.1 million profit a year ago, but considerably smaller than quarterly losses earlier in 2013. Pandora stock dipped just slightly to $29.11 in after hours trading.
It’s still tricky to ascertain exactly what impact iTunes Radio is having on Pandora. Though Apple’s service attracted 11 million unique users in its first five days on the market, its growth slowed afterward, and it attracted just 20 million users total through first month. Still, the service may have taken a small bite out of Pandora’s listenership, which declined for the first time this year in October, from 72.7 million to 70.9 million. However, total listener hours increased from 1.36 billion 1.47 billion in October, showing that Apple’s offering hasn’t yet affected Pandora’s bottom line.
Perhaps a greater worry than Apple is the fact that Pandora’s user growth is slowing in 2013. From October 2012 to September 2013, Pandora gained 11.7 million new active listeners, a 20 percent increase from 2012. But in the year prior the service gained 18.9 million new active listeners, a 47 percent increase. Total listener hours also dipped for the first time earlier this year, though Pandora quickly addressed the issue by removing the 40-hour monthly limit on mobile use in September.
Looming over all of Pandora’s revenue initiatives, though, is the massive cost of acquiring music. The company spent $87 million on content acquisition costs (performance royalties for music artists and labels) in the most recent quarter, a 32 percent increase from last year. So far, efforts to lower this expense have failed. An attempt to push legislation lowering royalty rates through Congress last year simply earned the company the ire of many musicians. Now it’s trying a new tactic as it plans to negotiate with the Copyright Royalty Board, the government body that will soon determine the royalty rates paid by radio services through the reset of the decade.
Like Spotify and other companies innovating in music distribution, Pandora has not yet proven that its model can create a profitable business. But it at least seems likely that the company will have more time to figure it out without Apple stealing all of its market share.