The issue of fast-food worker pay has been in the news a lot lately, after McDonald’s published a much maligned sample budget for its low-income workers that more or less proved how impossible it is for minimum-wage workers to support themselves, let alone a family. This story was followed by a now debunked report from the Huffington Post that argued that McDonald’s could double its restaurant workers’ pay by simply raising the price of a Big Mac by 68¢.
Henry Blodget of Business Insider took the argument further, writing that McDonald’s profits are so healthy that it could afford to raise wages without raising prices — and still remain profitable. As Ryan Chittum of the Columbia Journalism Review points out, this ignores the fact that most McDonald’s employees work for franchises, rather than the parent company, and that these franchises have a much lower profit margin than their corporate parent.
Much of this goes to show the danger of trying to extrapolate larger points from anecdotal and incomplete information. The fact is, franchise financial data is private, and even if McDonald’s and its franchises are wildly profitable, it may not say that much about the overall health of the restaurant industry. But looking at aggregate data from Sageworks, a private-company financial-data analytics firm, shows that private fast-food firms are doing quite well these days, and that they’re not sharing their profits with workers. According to Sageworks data:
- Profit margins for privately held fast-food companies are 4.6%, up from 2.1% in 2009
- Revenues over the past year are up 12.1%, following a 8.4% increase the previous year
- The percentage of revenue spent on payroll has decreased from 23.5% to 22.9%
That being said, a profit margin of 4.6% isn’t huge. At least, it’s not the sort of profitability that would allow most firms to double their wages. But it does show that whatever success these companies are having, they aren’t sharing it with employees.
And this isn’t just a problem with the fast-food industry. This comes at a time when wages have been almost completely stagnant. And corporate profit margins across the board have soared in recent years, while the median worker’s pay has stayed flat.
Regardless of how profitable McDonald’s is or isn’t, it’s clear that in the aggregate, many businesses could afford to pay their workers more. Can you really blame fast-food workers for realizing this fact and trying to force their bosses to share some of corporate America’s good fortune?