Cyprus: The E.U. ‘Rescue’ That Risks Backfiring

With its $13 billion agreement to bail out Cyprus, the E.U. this weekend thought that it had successfully doused the latest threat to its single currency, the euro. Cyprus has run into trouble because its banks are heavily exposed to Greek debt. Instead, the nature of the bailout – which features a levy on the bank deposits of ordinary Cypriots — has sparked a bank run on the island that threatens to spill over to other European countries.

The sudden eruption of panic could still be contained; European officials on Sunday night were looking to revise the terms of the agreement ahead of a vote on the rescue package in the Cypriot parliament, in order to shield smaller depositors. E.U. officials insist that Cyprus was always a special case. But by forcing ordinary citizens to fund the bank rescues up front, through a tax on deposits, the E.U. is setting a precedent that is chilling to people in other countries, like Spain, which has looked at a bailout for its own beleaguered banking system.

(MORE: Saving the Euro Zone, One Bank at a Time)

In an impassioned address on Cyprus TV on Sunday night, President Nicos Anastasiades said, “Cyprus is in a tragic situation,” but he argued that this rescue package was the best one for the island nation. “I chose the least painful option, and I bear the political cost for this, in order to limit as much as possible the consequences for the economy and for our fellow Cypriots,” he said.

The $13 billion bailout package may seem like chump change, but in fact it represents about 50% of Cyprus’ total economy. The Cypriot central-bank governor, Panicos Demetriades, has pointed out that, as a proportion of GDP, it is one of the largest bank bailouts ever, second only to the 1997 bank bailout in Indonesia.

The government first requested a bailout in June 2012 after the two biggest banks, Laiki Bank and Bank of Cyprus, racked up huge losses on their exposure to Greek debt and themselves needed to be rescued. The sticking point for E.U. officials, and especially for the German government, has long been Cyprus’ status as a haven for Russian money, at least some of which is widely assumed to be of dubious origin. The German national intelligence agency in November reportedly found that Russians had deposited as much as $26 billion in the island’s banks, prompting government fears that E.U. bailout funds would simply disappear into a bottomless pit of corruption.

(MORE: Why the Euro Crisis Is Nowhere Near Being Over)

At the insistence of both the E.U. and the IMF, Cyprus would only receive a bailout if as much as $6 billion of the money could be recouped from bank depositors. That solution was aimed primarily at the Russians and other wealthy depositors, with more than $130,000 in their accounts. But under the terms of the agreement finalized on Friday night, all depositors will take a hit. A one-time levy of 9.9% will be charged on deposits over $130,000, and accounts with less will be charged 6.75%.

Monday happens to be a bank holiday in Cyprus, so the agreement was supposed to take effect on Tuesday, following a vote by the Cyprus parliament. Electronic bank transfers were suspended and ATM withdrawals were limited — but even so the cash machines quickly ran dry as ordinary Cypriots rushed to withdraw as much money as they could.

The parliamentary vote, slated for Sunday, was postponed, and now looks like being a critical moment for the island’s politics: President Anastasiades’ party has only 20 of the 56 seats in parliament. In his TV address on Sunday, he insisted that he was seeking to strike a revised and more favorable deal for small depositors. But opposition leaders are rejecting the deal. All in all, it’s a volatile mix that looks sure to rattle markets around the world until the situation is resolved.

MORE: Europe’s Good News: Economic Decline Is Bad, but Could Be Worse

25 comments
famulla5
famulla5

Washington's gridlock appears to have eased just enough to avoid a shutdown of the federal government, but its budget battles are far from over. Congress is finally poised to pass a bipartisan funding bill that will clean up its unfinished business for the long-underway 2013 budget year. The Senate, controlled by Democrats, is expected to approve the catchall-spending bill Tuesday. The Republican-held House of Representatives, which has already passed its own version, is then expected to quickly clear the measure and ship it to President Barack for his signature. I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

famulla5
famulla5

The Cyprus banking tax-bomb should be a wake up call for everyone everywhere that has some money saved for whatever reason. It's the left's next salvo in their mad attempt to achieve equality of outcomes in everything and everywhere. I strongly doubt the Cypriots came up with this idea on their own. If I were a central banker in the Euro zone struggling to deal with economies on the brink of economic meltdown for lack of money to pay for the cradle-to-grave gravy train, it is an idea worth exploring. It's this type of craziness that keeps the left in near perpetual political power. Cyprus is the ideal small-scale experiment. I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

famulla5
famulla5

According to a poll conducted by the "Rating" group, if presidential elections in Ukraine were held this past February, the second place would go to the leader of the "UDAR" party, world boxing champion Vitali Klitschko. With voters participation at 70%, Viktor Yanukovych would get 25.1%, Vitaly Klitschko 15.1%, Yulia Tymoshenko 13.9%, "Svoboda" leader Oleg Tyahnybok - 7.9 %, communist leader Petro Symonenko - 7.7%, the "Fatherland" party leader Yatsenyuk - 7.4%. Among all respondents 11.1% were still undecided.
If the second round was held between Yanukovych and Tymoshenko, she would beat him 36.4% vs. 33.2%. If the second round was held with Klitschko, Yanukovych would score only 30.2%, while Klitschko can count on 49% of the country's electorate. Not encouraging for Yanukovych no matter who will be his opponent. I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

famulla5
famulla5

We need the troops back not the  bread baking lessons from any. You see, for the last five years, the U.S. and EU governments have been stealing trillions of dollars of taxpayer funds for the banking system as follows:

  • 0% Interest rates (ZIRP) — The governments lend the banks money at 0% interest and then borrow it back from the banks at 2%-3% or even in the EU’s case, 10% plus. It’s riskless profits for the banks and it costs the taxpayers trillions every year.
  • TARP and other direct bailouts — The governments have literally written dozens of trillion dollar welfare checks for the banks shareholders to distribute in dividends and bonuses since 2008.
  • Implicit TBTF guarantee — Recent studies show that the TBTF banks save 10s of billions of dollars in interest costs every year because the marketplace (their lenders) knows that the governments will bail them out if the bank runs into any major problems.
  • The banks pay out less than 1% interest on deposits while charging up to 30%-plus for interest on loans.
  • MF Global and its TBTF trading partners stole billions of dollars directly from the accounts of farmers and ranchers to gamble on EU-debt derivatives and lost. And nobody went to jail.
  • Banks are paying you .25% on the money in your checking account while inflation of 5% plus (or whatever the real inflation rate really is) makes every one of those dollars worth less on a daily basis.
  • Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac get saddled with trillions in losses as the banks cherry pick the securities they buy and sell these taxpayer-funded entities.
  • The banks get to sell trillions of dollars of worthless mortgage and government debt securities to the Federal Reserve at full value through the magic of Quantitative Easing.
  • The banks got the regulators and accounting boards to allow them to mark most of their assets to whatever value they think they should be worth whenever they need them to be worth it.-- I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

famulla5
famulla5

You jest sir, How can you have the neighbouring state bleed and you have the high hopes of revival  This is economically wrong in the new IT age and the Trade barriers we have set , we did the wrong, we cannot do this right now  The pound slips because the bloody bankers want it to. When are people going to wake up to the fact the money men think they can control nations by fiddling with the currency markets, Share prices and even threaten to take other people's money directly from their savingsI thank you Firozali A.Mulla

famulla5
famulla5

EURO NOW ...I agree with this article and with Obama; We have nothing to worry about from Cyprus, the debt and the deficits. Add a trillion a year to the debt, run it up to 17 trillion, 20 trillion, no problem!
Obama wants to turn the US into a socialist welfare state, so he'll have permanent slave class ready to keep him in power, no problem. Free food, shelter, education, healthcare..no problem!
No worries at all. When the government goes broke along with my bank, I'll just keep spending and having fun.
What a great life! What a great Nation! I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

bojimbo26
bojimbo26

The government will pocket 90% of the money .

famulla5
famulla5

Theft is not a name for legalising. "Essentially parliament is called to legalise a decision to rob depositors blind, against every written and unwritten law," said Yiannakis Omirou, speaker of Cypriot parliament and head of EDEK, the small Socialist party. "Despite reassurances from Brussels that Cyprus is a special case and that indiscriminate levies won't be a common policy tool, depositors across Europe are doubting their sincerity and are fearing that a new precedent has been set for other debt-laden euro zone countries," Jonathan Sudaria, dealer at Capital Spreads, said. "It is as if the Europeans are holding up a neon sign, written in Greek and Italian, saying 'Time to stage a run on your banks!'" US economist Paul Krugman wrote in The New York Times. Northern Rockwas a British bank, most recently owned and operated byVirgin Money. It was based atRegent CentreinNewcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom. During 2012 the Northern Rock brand was phased out and replaced by Virgin. Northern Rock was best known for becoming the first bank in 150 years to suffer abank runafter having had to approach the Bank of England for a loan facility, to replacemoney market funding, during thecredit crisis in 2007.[2]Having failed to find a commercial buyer for the business, it was taken into public ownership in 2008, and was then bought byVirgin Moneyin 2012. Formerly theNorthern Rock Building Society, the bank was formed in 1997 when thesocietyfloated on theLondon Stock Exchange(with the ticker symbol NRK). Since 1 January 2010 when it was split into a 'good' and a 'bad' bank, the "Northern Rock" name has referred to two companies – this bank, Northern Rock, and a separate asset company I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

famulla5
famulla5

The European Union's markets watchdog has criticised the world's top three ratings agencies over a lack of transparency over how they evaluate banks and has demanded more robust internal reviews of their methods. 

The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), which studied Moody's, Fitch and Standard & Poor's , said there was inadequate disclosure of the in-house methodologies used to compile their ratings and how they keep these methods under review. 

Announcing the results of its second annual review of the banking sector on Monday, ESMA said that it looked at bank ratings because of their close link to ratings of government debt, a focus of the euro zone crisis.  I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

famulla5
famulla5

Greek Taxpayer's statement that, "loans are never paid back" and "do you believe the Greek loans will ever be paid back?," is historically verified by the heavy borrowing that Germany did from New York banks after WWI and consistently defaulted on paying anything back, just as the country defaulted on other parts of reparations and war loans. Famously, the government even inflated the currency to get out of its obligations, to the nation's detriment. Of course, it all worked out when German debt was significantly forgiven to a manageable level in the early 1950s. All's well that ends well. I thank you FirozaliA.Mulla DBA

famulla5
famulla5

A eurozone plan to bail out the nation of Cyprus has rattled stock markets around the world. The package requires a tax on bank accounts to help pay for the bailout.

The tax has raised fears of a bank run and concerns about the safety of bank accounts in other European Union countries.

"The Cyprus bailout highlights the continued weak links in the system," Morgan Stanley banking analyst Huw van Steenis told investors in a research note Monday. "The pressure on many European banks, particularly the mid-cap peripherals, is intense."

Cyprus President Nicos Anastasiades said the plan is necessary to prevent the country from going bankrupt. He's urging parliament to vote for the tax.

"I completely share the unpleasant sentiment that this difficult and onerous decision has caused," Anastasiades said. "That's why I continue to give battle so that the decisions of the eurozone are amended in the next hours to limit the effect on small depositors."

Some lawmakers have refused to vote for the tax. If parliament rejects the levy, that could put the entire bailout plan in jeopardy. I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

famulla5
famulla5

What would happen if most young Americans could get jobs or afford college and quit volunteering to join the military? Well, it wouldn’t be so easy for our
political leaders to start wars. Regarding free tuition for active duty military personal, the writer states: “This is a key element of the basic compact between the U.S.
government and all young Americans who agree to enlist and risk their lives to
protect the United States”. One correction. In the last ten years these young Americans who risked their lives, did not protect the United States. 
They enabled the political leaders of the United States to pursue two misguided and stupid wars that have jeopardized the economic security and welfare of our country. I was drafted during the Vietnam War and I’m sure that one of the most powerful
forces that finally prevailed in bringing that grotesque mistake of a war to an
end was all those young Americans, who were subject to the draft, marching in
the streets and fleeing to Canada. Let’s end the all volunteer army and make it harder for the politicians to start wars. I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

Bullsgt
Bullsgt

I agree with AngelaWalker. This is a test and we should voice opposition to it. If the Cyprus government needs to tax assets they should start with the banking/financial industry leaders and the watchdogs who are supposed to prevent these poor banking practices.

famulla5
famulla5

What an ugly precedent in Cyprus. The government completely mismanages the public finances so everyone in the country pays for it, even the lower income people. But is that any different from the true reality? In our country everyone is going to pay too, not just the rich thru higher taxes. Everyone will pass via: a) higher inflation and the pass thru effect of higher taxes. When you hit business owners and corporations with higher taxes, they just pass that along in prices that everyone pays. Cyprus was just a little more direct (and honest!) by whacking everyone right out of the box!  I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

JohnDavidDeatherage
JohnDavidDeatherage

Talk about the law of unintended consequences... How did they expect deposit holders to react?  A run on banks is a reasonable reaction to taxing deposits.


famulla5
famulla5

Theft is not a name for legalising. "Essentially parliament is called to legalise a decision to rob depositors blind, against every written and unwritten law," said Yiannakis Omirou, speaker of Cypriot parliament and head of EDEK, the small Socialist party. "Despite reassurances from Brussels that Cyprus is a special case and that indiscriminate levies won't be a common policy tool, depositors across Europe are doubting their sincerity and are fearing that a new precedent has been set for other debt-laden euro zone countries," Jonathan Sudaria, dealer at Capital Spreads, said. "It is as if the Europeans are holding up a neon sign, written in Greek and Italian, saying 'Time to stage a run on your banks!'" US economist Paul Krugman wrote in The New York Times. Northern Rockwas a British bank, most recently owned and operated byVirgin Money. It was based atRegent CentreinNewcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom. During 2012 the Northern Rock brand was phased out and replaced by Virgin. Northern Rock was best known for becoming the first bank in 150 years to suffer abank runafter having had to approach the Bank of England for a loan facility, to replacemoney market funding, during thecredit crisis in 2007.[2]Having failed to find a commercial buyer for the business, it was taken into public ownership in 2008, and was then bought byVirgin Moneyin 2012. Formerly theNorthern Rock Building Society, the bank was formed in 1997 when thesocietyfloated on theLondon Stock Exchange(with the ticker symbol NRK). Since 1 January 2010 when it was split into a 'good' and a 'bad' bank, the "Northern Rock" name has referred to two companies – this bank, Northern Rock, and a separate asset company I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

famulla5
famulla5

We are investigating this now that cost millions of $ and hundreds of lives Do we not know this?. The whole WMD was fracas caused by Bush , Tony Blaire , Collin Powell , Condoles Rice and some more I thank you Firozali A.Mulla DBA

Victori41697771
Victori41697771

I get paid over $87 per hour working from home with 2 kids at home. I never thought I'd be able to do it but my best friend earns over 10k a month doing this and she convinced me to try. The potential with this is endless. Heres what I've been doing, Great60.comCHECK IT OUT


mikerana
mikerana

So as a foreigner, I lose faith in Cyprus, which once I thought was heaven .. and I wrote about it. Why do the manipulators eat away money of the innocent investors ? It happened to provident funds in Russia. It is happening in Cyprus .. May be Cyprus has become a tax hell instead of its being a tax haven.

efrustrated
efrustrated

Difficult to predict what the consequences of this will eventually be, but hey, I'm just a "man in the street", the EU Economics geniuses couldn't even predict what the immediate reaction would be. 

They and their rapacious banking buddies will not be regarded well when this series of charades is finally recorded as history.

AngelaWalker
AngelaWalker like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

A test-run to see how the population responds to the direct appropriation of their funds.