Why a Business Major is No Longer the Ticket

  • Share
  • Read Later
Getty Images

The Great Recession has dramatically changed the way we value a college education. First came the argument that a college degree isn’t worth the cost. Now we’re bashing the venerable business degree.

The backdrop, of course, is historic disappointment with post-graduate opportunities. The unemployment rate for new college grads is the highest in years and an estimated 26% of those aged 25 to 34 can’t find work. That doesn’t square with nearly $1 trillion outstanding in student loans. You can understand how some would question the value of a college degree.

(MORE: Fixing Faddish Earlobe Holes Can Cost Thousands)

Meanwhile, pay on Wall Street—where a lot of top business majors hope to land—is going down. Compensation this year will be the lowest since the financial crisis, and the partners at bellwether firm Goldman Sachs are bracing for bonuses that are half or less than what they got last year.

Worse for business majors, new research suggests that the major is overcrowded with underachieving students and that businesses themselves value the discipline less. College expert and blogger Lynn O’Shaughnessy writes:

“Not pursuing an undergrad business degree can actually boost the chances of getting into MBA programs. At some schools, less than 25% of students have an undergrad business degree.”

She goes on to note that the blockbuster book, Academically Adrift, posits that business students learn the least in college and that a new report from the National Survey of Student Engagement concludes business majors study less than other college students.

One in five students pursues a business degree, which is probably more than the world needs. As O’Shaughnessy writes:

“What employers really want, according to workplace surveys, are college grads who can think effectively, communicate and write. Students can obtain these skills from any major, but plenty of research has concluded that students who earn degrees in the liberal arts enjoy a better chance of meeting these job requirements.”

I don’t buy the argument that college is a waste of money. A body of research shows that grads earn a lot more money than non-grads over the course of their life. That doesn’t mean student loans aren’t a huge problem for those with degrees and no job. It’s a good idea to attend college on the cheap—state schools, community college credits—if you are pursuing a low paying or crowded field. But for most grads the payoff should be there.

(MORE: Will Tensions With Iran Really Push Gasoline to $5 a Gallon?)

A business degree is another thing. This line of study probably has become too popular. Colleges are minting money-focused graduates in a work world that increasingly values critical thinking and softer skills like the ability to communicate. Today’s workplaces often offer more opportunities for those centered on intrinsic rewards like doing what makes them happy and making a difference. The long maligned liberal arts degree may be more practical than you think.

And make sure to fit some serious math courses in between all those English and history seminars: The 20 best-paying college degrees in 2011 all required advanced math skills, according to compensation firm PayScale.


Well, I studied a business major (not on my own accord) and all I got was a few low-end jobs which I could have gotten with just my O levels with nothing to do with my major and learning very little in my course. It's the business school counterpart of a liberal arts degree.

It's a waste of time and money, and has an oversaturated job market.


Happy new year, everyone, I have a opposite view about this.

“Where is the Best Place to Invest $102,000 -- In Stocks, Bonds, or a College Degree?” by Michael Greenstone and Adam Looney (June 25, 2011), from NPR’s paper. The authors report on the issue of the benefits of investing in college degree. It‘s obviously that higher education is better investment than any other alternatives. First, studies show that if a person chooses to invest in college, he will gain more opportunities and more salary until he is sixty five years old. He will earn seventy percents more than a high school degree. Second, according to the research, an investment in four-year College can get fifteen point two percents feedback, which is more than double the average return in the stock market. Because of that, the greatest investment is in college degree.

I agree to the statement in this news report for the following reasons. First of all, although many people say that the job market remains tough even for college graduates, I consider that those with college degrees, on average, earn far more than those without them. For example, during the Great Recession, almost 90% of these young college graduates were employed in 2010, compared with only 64% of their peers who did not attend college. Another example is that in much recruitment such as TSMC, college degree is the basic condition to be hired. The second reason is that according to NPR’s paper, a student graduate from college can earn six times salary than from high school. Furthermore, the salary range depends on your major. To illustrate, a college majored in engineer who could earn more money than a high school. Last but not the least, going to a college can learn not only professional majors but also abilities like organization and negotiation. For example, having a project with a team, we need to discuss with each other and gather ideas to fulfill it.

I know some people disagree that investing in college education is a great choice, but I have to say that college degree is a ticket, I cannot promise if you graduate from college, you could find a perfect job, but high school one is obviously much difficult, so I still believe that it’s a long-term investment that pays off over time because we can learn lots of things which can’t be replacement from college.