A Donor Makes the Case That Kidney Sales Should Be Legal

  • Share
  • Read Later
Getty Images

The buying and selling of human organs is generally frowned upon. But should this be the case? There’s an argument to be made that if kidney sales were legal, more lives could be saved (because more people would be willing to part with a kidney), and overall health care costs would decline (because a kidney transplant is cheap compared to years of dialysis and treatment). And what’s the suggested fair retail price for a kidney? About $50,000.

In a New York Times op-ed, Alexander Berger presses the idea that the selling (or buying) of a kidney should be completely legal and open to everyone. Berger is not a doctor or an academic. He doesn’t work in the health care field at all. He’s only 21 years old. So why should we care about his opinion?

Well, he has quite an interesting point of view. Berger is in the process of donating a kidney to someone he’s never met. He’ll endure what he calls a “safe and relatively painless” procedure that’ll required him to spend three days in the hospital and take several weeks off from work (at a nonprofit charity research foundation). And why is he doing this? Berger sees the donating of a kidney as little more than “one of the many ways a reasonably altruistic person can help others.”

Berger holds that his personal sacrifice is outweighed by the good that’ll come of his anonymous donation—namely, that the recipient should wind up living roughly 10 extra years. Relatively pain- and hassle-free years at that.

(MORE: Lipitor Already Cheaper After Patent Expiration)

Berger acknowledges that most people don’t feel the same way as him. If they did, the waiting lists for kidneys wouldn’t be quite so enormous, and thousands of people wouldn’t die each year while waiting for a kidney. He writes that friends and family view the donation more as “a crazy act of self-sacrifice” than a logical response to help.

What, Berger wonders, would happen if the removal of one’s kidney wasn’t perceived as “crazy,” or even particularly unselfish? What if it was legal for money to enter the equation? What if the donor became more of a business partner—an individual who owns something valuable, and who would be fairly compensated for giving it up?

Berger isn’t suggesting that the recipients actually foot the bill for kidneys. That’d only help those rich enough to drop tens of thousands of dollars on a kidney, and it’d likely create an ugly auction-type situation, with people outbidding each other to keep their loved ones alive. Instead, Berger—and plenty of others, including plenty in the fields of medicine and ethics—propose a well-regulated legal market for kidneys, in which only government agencies or specified nonprofits could purchase the organs. Then …

they would allocate them on the basis of need rather than wealth, the same way that posthumously donated organs are currently distributed. The kidneys would be paid for by whoever covers the patient, whether that is their insurance company or Medicare. Ideally, so many donors would come forward that no patient would be left on the waiting list.

(MORE: What Darwin Might Tell Us About Black Friday)

Compared to dialysis and treatment for a patient in need of a kidney, a transplant generally saves roughly $100,000. That means that even when factoring in a payment of $50,000 to the donor, a legalized kidney marketplace winds up saving money.

Because monetary compensation is very likely to attract more donors looking to cash in on the assets in their abdomens, such a system is also likely to save more people too.

Brad Tuttle is a reporter at TIME. Find him on Twitter at @bradrtuttle. You can also continue the discussion on TIME’s Facebook page and on Twitter at @TIME.

7 comments
infokidneycenter
infokidneycenter

Are you in debt or financially handicap and want to sell your kidney? Are you physically ill-heath and in need of a kidney donor? Kindly contact us today, Agency for local and international kidney sale and donation(ALIKSD) We render our best in aiding people sell and donate their kidney effectively without any side effect. Email : infokidneycenter@gmail.com

Thanks!

Dr.Ehis
Dr.Ehis

I am Dr. EHIS PhD, here with interest on anyone willing to buy or sell his/her organ (kidney). Please Note: In the internet there are a lot of people with different motives, so please be sincere and truthful because we are not kids, this is about saving lives of others. Lives are at stake. Fraudulent act is not accepted please. Interested persons should email me via docspec94@gmail.com

SmithaBabu
SmithaBabu



dear sir/madam



Do you want to sell your kidney? Are you seeking for an opportunity to

sell your kidney for money due to financial break down and you don’t

know what to do, then contact us today and we shall offer you good

amount for your Kidney. My name is (Doctor Darbar Sahib) am a

Phrenologist in maxhospital25@gmail.com. Our hospital is specialized in

Kidney Surgery and we also deal with buying and transplantation of

kidneys with a living an corresponding donor. We are located in

Indian, Turkey, USA,Malaysia.



contact us via maxhospital25@gmail.com

brentjimmy5
brentjimmy5

I'm Doctor Micheal Ibadin,I am the representative doctor of University of Benin Teaching Hospital(UBTH),I have been given the opportunity by the hospital management to advertise on net how we operate,we are specialist in organ surgery and transplantation of human organs, we also deal in the buying and selling of human organs like kidney and liver,if you are interested to sell your kidney to us,you are advice to get back to us with the email below so that we can proceed further.
We are located in USA,MALAYSIA,INDIA and NIGERIA and our head office is located in NIGERIA.
Please get back to us with the below email:
ubthospital.representative@gmail.com

Eddyluv
Eddyluv

We wish to give out loan to whom ever that is in need of a loan  at low 

interest rate of  2%. We give out loan from the minimum of 1,000.00 Usd to 

the maximum 100 million dollars, pounds, euros. If interested,  Contact us 

via email: purefunding.cash@gmail.com

We offer the following kinds of loans and  many more;

* Personal Loans ( Unsecured Loan)

* Business Loans ( Unsecured Loan)

* Consolidation Loan

* Combination Loan

* Home Improvement

* New Year Loan

All REPLIES SHOULD BE SENT TO THIS EMAIL: purefunding.cash@gmail.com


Eddyluv
Eddyluv

Hello friends,

you don't need to pay any fees,We will take care of your accommodation and food and travelling and medical expenses

You don't need to worry we will show right path Email us : dr-robinsonadams@outlook.com

Fahad
Fahad

My Self Fahad. I am from India but now I am living in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. I am 28 Years old. I want to sell my kidney. I have no bad habits. My blood group is AB+ Please contact me My email ID is: fahadshamim99gmail.com