Financial re-regulation: did we reach a middle ground?

Financial re-regulation: check! Here’s a great graphic summarizing what wound up in the final bill. For each category of re-regulation, Jon Hilsenrath explains what problems existed, the solutions Congress came up with and the chances that those solutions will work. It’s a great compilation, one worth checking out.

As I’ve been digging into the details of the final bill, I’ve been struck by how middle-of-the-road it seems. Yes, some people are claiming that the new legislation goes way too far and will devastate the availability of credit, and others are saying that it went nowhere near far enough and will do little to prevent the next crisis. Increasingly, though, I think that the truth might lie  pretty much in the middle—that for all the political posturing, we wound up with a decent bill that strikes a legitimate compromise between making the financial system safer and preserving its ability to innovate.

In the WSJ‘s monthly poll of economists, most felt optimistic about the outcome. Seventy-eight percent said that the bill “slightly,” “modestly” or “significantly” reduced the risk of a repeat of a 2008-style financial crisis. Many more economists were in the “slightly” than the “significantly” camp, but considering all the rhetoric around how this bill would grind the economy to a halt, I’d count that as a victory.

Of course, as my colleague Adam Sorensen explains, there are still plenty of details to work out. But the bill is passed and the biggest questions are answered. Now we wait and see what happens the next time a massive asset bubble is lobbed our way.

UPDATE: Matt Yglesias agrees with me.

Related Topics: Congress, financial re-regulation, Wall Street & Markets
  • Latest on Business

    Thomas Patterson / Statesman-Journal / AP

    The Bleak Unemployment Report: Is Europe to Blame?

    For the first time in almost a year, the unemployment rate rose to 8.2% in May as the economic recovery appeared to not only slow but almost completely stall. And it gets worse.

    The Jury Is Out on the EuroSlate

    Getty Images

    Smartphones of the Future: 6 Predictions

    Future mobile devices will change the way you do business–in ways you probably can’t even imagine. Here are a few predictions.

  • deconstructiva

    Barbara, thanks for this wrapup and for linking Adam’s wrapup. Make sure he returns the favor later today or this weekend. Would you consider doing one of his The Call™ swampland podcasts, perhaps with Jay Newton-Small and Michael Scherer on a financial reform summary?
    .
    As for FR bill, I agree with Adam that this is the beginning, not the end as traders / bankers now will try to skirt the rules (trade overseas, create new financial monsters that don’t legally fall in regulated categories, etc.). One question for you and your team: remembering how our financial collapse spread to Europe, how do you see an overseas collapse affecting us / future FR? For example: China. They haven’t had their Big Crash yet like we have. They have real estate bubbles, rising inventories, etc. and we’re tied way too close (they buy our debt / we buy their goods at Walmart). If they collapse, how can we protect ourselves within fin. reform, if possible?
    .
    Are there future fin. ref. tweaks you two can see, such as how our traders / banks deal w. overseas items, or is that out of our hands? Thanks for your thoughts, and have a great weekend.

  • timothydillian

    Thanks Barbara, You’re the best.

  • Barbara Kiviat

    Thanks!

blog comments powered by Disqus