What regulators are good for: Cleaning up

Hedge fund manager and poker ace David Einhorn was the speaker at the 17th annual Graham & Dodd breakfast Friday morning. I arrived too late to get a seat, and left early because I was starving, but I did write down this quote:

Regulators are good at cleaning up fraud after the money is gone. Government doesn’t really know what to do when it catches fraud in progress.

Einhorn was talking mainly about his long-running battle with investment firm Allied Capital over its accounting practices. He’s got a book about the saga coming out next year, and if the excerpt he read at the breakfast–about a grilling he underwent at the hands of two SEC lawyers–was any indication, it should be pretty entertaining.

But the lesson is a broader one: It is incredibly hard for government officials to step in and try to stop behavior that they think is illegal or unwise at companies that seem to be making lots of money off this behavior. It’s even harder if it’s an entire industry, such as, say, the subprime mortgage lenders of a couple years ago. Try to crack down while the party is still going and you’re likely to get hauled in front of Congressional committees, lambasted in the media and attacked by aggressive company lawyers. Wait until it all falls apart and, while you’ll still get lambasted a bit, most of the discussions in the media and Congress will be about how to give you more resources and power in the future.

Related Topics: Economy & Policy
  • Latest on Business

    Associated Press

    Apple CEO Cook Gives Up $75M in Stock Dividends

    NEW YORK — Apple CEO Tim Cook is giving up $75 million in dividends on restricted stock that the company is awarding to all of its employees.

    In a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission on Thursday, Apple Inc. said that Cook requested that his restricted stock units not receive dividends. The dividends that Apple workers are getting amount to $2.65 per quarter for each restricted stock unit held. The shares are not normally eligible to receive dividends, so Apple’s decision is a perk for its employees.

    The Bomb Hidden in Mitt Romney's Education PlanSlate

    Associated Press

    Study: Typical CEO Pay Up 6% to $9.6 Million

    NEW YORK — Profits at big U.S. companies broke records last year, and so did pay for CEOs.

    The head of a typical public company made $9.6 million in 2011, according to an analysis by The Associated Press using data from Equilar, an executive pay research firm.

  • p_lukasiak

    Jay, you don’t seem to be considering the question of who is running the guvernment at the time that irregularities are first discovered. For 18 of the last 26 years, the people in charge have been obsessed with “less government regulation” — often putting people who are philosophically opposed to regulation in charge of agencies that are supposed to regulate.

    In other words, is it really “government” that is ineffective… or “Republican government” that aren’t into regulating in the first place?

  • Justin Fox

    Clearly that’s part of it: If you don’t believe in regulation, you’re unlikely to be very good at it. But I don’t think it’s the whole story.

  • http://curiouscapitalist.blogs.time.com/2009/01/05/are-regulators-ever-going-to-be-good-at-stopping-fraud/ The Curious Capitalist – TIME.com » Blog Archive Are regulators ever going to be good at stopping fraud? «

    [...] preferred the much shorter diagnosis that Einhorn made in a speech in 2007: Regulators are good at cleaning up fraud after the money is gone. Government doesn’t really know [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus