The cellphone police, coming soon to a school near you

As part of this week’s continuing series on my son’s friends’ siblings in the news, here’s an interesting story from today’s NYT:

When Olivia Lara-Gresty saw the metal detectors at the entrance of Middle School 54 on the Upper West Side, she turned around and ran home to ditch her contraband before joining her sixth-grade class.

The cellphone police had arrived.

Not everyone was so savvy. The Police Department was there to carry out a random sweep for prohibited items, requiring all 900-plus students at the school to walk through metal detectors before entering.

Their total haul included 404 cellphones, 69 iPods, 23 other electronic devices, two knives and one imitation gun.

Good for Olivia! And I’m on the side of the many parents who think the Bloomberg administration has gone way over the line with this no-cellphones-in-schools thing. In Manhattan, parents generally start letting their kids roam the streets unaccompanied (for brief periods, at least) around 5th grade. They give the kids cellphones so they can call them every five minutes because they’re worried. What’s so wrong about that?

Spain’s Prime Minister Warns Country Is in Danger of Being Shut Out of Markets

MADRID — Spain‘s prime minister warned Wednesday that the country faced the danger of being locked out of international markets as investors continued to fret about the future of the euro and Greece’s place in the 17-country eurozone.

“Right now there is a serious risk that (investors) will not lend us money or they will do so at an astronomical rate,” Mariano Rajoy told Spanish lawmakers.

wood turtle

Those are difficult ages, from about 10 to high school. They are too old for day care, but you can’t comfortably leave them on their own. I think you should be allowed to give the children cell phones also.
http://www.oursheet.com mario Ruiz

I am sure the debate is hot. On one side we have security issues that cell phones can help our kids as you point out, and on the other side we have learning problems at the school.

Along these lines, my kids and their friends are experts at sending messages. They can type the message without seeing the little keyboard. They communicate to each other during classes.

What they do at my son school is to put little save boxes to keep the cell phones during classes. When the leave the ca take and used to their discretion.

Mario Ruiz

Visit http://www.oursheet.com

If you need servers just click http://www.shoppingsun.net
Latimer Jones

A good idea for parents to keep in touch with their kids for safety. This poses a problem in abusing the privilage of having the phone; communicating with friends while in class, or receiving calls midclass. This problem is evident in many classroom environments. For instance in Asia, students studying english will receive calls midclass to receive instructions by another for how to sabotage the instructor`s lesson or embarrass the instructor. This is often met with a rule of no phone during class.

This could be applied to the Upper West Side where students either power off their phones or dont use them at all while in class, but able to receive a call from parents.
surlygrad

Cell phones didn’t become a common consumer item until 2000-2001. To assert that they are now a “necessity” is absurd.
Ivan

Just make rules and enforce them. Our children’s school allows Cell Phones. The students are required to turn off them during class or the cell will be confiscated and only the authorized representative (parent or other guardian) of the student will be allowed to retrieve it from the principal’s office. I think the Cell phone has become an invaluable tool to communicate with our children. We don’t call them every 5 minutes. If anybody does that, he or she requires urgent sicological counseling. Another rule for our children (enforced by many parents): always answer our call or your cell phone will be confiscated by us and you grounded for a week. When I was a child we didn’t need cellphones, and when our grandparents were children they did’nt need measles vaccination, but if those are available today, why not take advantage of their clear benefits.